NewsTop Stories

Fort Portal High Court dismisses Bundibugyo Woman MP election petition

Tayari News

The High Court in Fort Portal has dismissed an election petition challenging the victory of Bundibugyo District Woman Member of Parliament Josephine Bebona Babungi.

In a judgment delivered on Monday by Magistrate Ronald Ssebandeke on behalf of Justice Joanita Gertrude Bushara, court upheld Babungi’s election and ordered that she retains her seat in Parliament.

The petition was filed by independent candidate Donna Kamuli Kapalaya, who challenged Babungi’s victory in the January 15 parliamentary elections, alleging discrepancies in the results, manipulation of votes, forged signatures and other electoral irregularities.

The Electoral Commission declared Babungi, who contested on the National Resistance Movement (NRM) ticket, the winner with 34,169 votes against Kapalaya’s 32,182.

Kapalaya argued that the election was not conducted in accordance with electoral laws and that she had obtained the highest number of valid votes. She accused Babungi and people allegedly acting with her knowledge of engaging in electoral offences like bribery, violence, threats and intimidation.

However, in its assessment of the disputed results court found that although there were discrepancies between some original and certified declaration of results forms, the petitioner had not sufficiently demonstrated that the differences resulted from unlawful additions to Babungi’s votes.

The court also found that the evidence did not provide a reliable alternative tally to establish that Kapalaya had obtained the highest number of valid votes.

On allegations that the electoral irregularities substantially affected the outcome, Justice Bushara found that some inaccuracies and operational shortcomings had been established.

However, Kapalaya had failed to prove that they substantially affected the election either quantitatively or qualitatively.The judge also dismissed allegations of electoral offences including bribery, intimidation, threats and the use of public projects to influence voters, saying the petitioner had not established that Babungi personally committed or authorised the alleged offences.

The court nevertheless raised concerns about the Electoral Commission’s handling and reconciliation of election results, noting that the discrepancies warranted judicial scrutiny.

On costs, the court ordered Kapalaya and the Electoral Commission to share equally the costs incurred by Babungi in defending the petition, noting that the discrepancies largely arose from the Commission’s management of election returns.

While speaking to URN after the judgment, Babungi welcomed the decision, saying it had confirmed her victory. She said she will now concentrate on fulfilling the promises in her manifesto and continue serving the people of Bundibugyo.However, Kapalaya expressed dissatisfaction with the ruling and announced plans to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

She noted that the judgment was shallow and could have been done in a rush.She maintains that she obtained the highest number of votes, urging her supporters not to lose hope.

-URN-

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *